Best $5 Easter Basket stuffers
Creating great Easter baskets doesn’t have to break the bank. This post has the best $5 Easter Basket stuffers. Some item are sets that can be broken up into gifts for more than one basket. I hope that this list helps you find great Easter basket gifts for all those you love. For more great Easter basket ideas, check out this blog post of 101 Easter Basket Ideas too.
All links are paid affiliate links and prices can change at any time.
Toy & Game Ideas
Slime eggs (5 pack): Easter themed slime – so fun!
Play-Doh eggs: Play-doh, but make it Easter.
Tic Tac Toe (6 pack): Endless fun with this tic tac toe
Stress ball (4 pack): These balls are fun and perfect for sensory lovers.
Pokemon cards: A hit every time!
Connect 4 card game: A clever twist on the popular game.
Spot It!: Every family needs this game.
Hatching unicorn egg: Unicorns in eggs – yes!
Floam eggs (3 pack): These play floam eggs are cute and come with a toy on the inside.
Easter Pop It (4 pack): Pop Its are so cute and these are on theme.
Grow capsule safari animals: My kids love these.
Nerf Better Than Balloons: These are so cool because they break in one piece!
Nerf Easy Blaster: A small nerf gun that’s perfectly sized for a basket.
Slinky: A classic toy that is always fun.
YoYo: Another great classic.
Tech Deck finger skateboard: This is fun for kids young and old
4″ Squishmallow blind plush: These mystery Squishmallows are always exciting.
Nee Doh Marble egg: Nee Doh is so fun to play with
$5 Craft Ideas
Easter Egg paint kit: This is such a fun set for eggs that will last!
Wood bunny paint kit: These wood bunnies are the perfect Easter activity.
Easter craft sticks: This craft is so cute.
Birdhouse craft kit: This will be enjoyed all spring.
Watercolor paints: New watercolors are always needed. Nothing like a fresh palette!
Silly Scents markers: Scented markers are a delightful treat.
Rainbow necklace kit: Bead making is so popular right now.
Easter egg stampers: These stampers are really cute.
Book Ideas
Easter Mad Libs: Mad Libs is so fun to enjoy at Easter brunch.
Coloring book: This coloring book is so sweet.
Stickers: SO many stickers!
Hidden Pictures book: Highlights makes the best hidden pictures books.
Paint by Sticker: My son loves this!
How to Catch the Easter Bunny: This is such a silly book!
Water Wow!: Love that these only need water to enjoy.
When God Made You: The sweetest book that every home needs.
Stencil set: Love all the activities in this.
Never Touch a Grumpy Bunny: This is fun for younger kids.
The Tale of Peter Rabbit: A classic tale that is perfect for Easter.
$5 or less fun treats
Starburst jellybeans: Jellybeans are the quintessential Easter basket stuffer.
Cadbury chocolate eggs: Every basket needs chocolate eggs.
Kinder egg: Kids love the chocolate on one side and small toy on the other.
Peeps chicks: Easter Peeps are a classic.
Robin eggs: Malted milk ball chocolate eggs – perfect for Easter baskets.
Easter mug: Such a cute mug. Perfect for hot chocolate.
Chocolate bunny: Every Easter basket needs a chocolate bunny.
Cotton candy: Such a cute little bunny treat.
Pez: Our family loves Pez. A great addition for stuffing their Easter basket.
Bubbletape: A childhood classic and a fun addition for their basket.
Bunny tumbler: How fun is this bunny tumbler!? Sure to delight your child this Easter.
Beauty & Clothing ideas
Daisy claw clips: Claw clips are super popular and these flowers are perfect for Spring.
Spa headband (3 pack): These cozy headbands make for a fun treat for your Easter basket stuffing.
Easter socks (3 pack): This 3 pack of Easter socks are a great non-candy choice for adding to baskets.
Pop fidget purse: A pop-fidget purse is such a fun little treat for your girl’s basket.
Lipsmacker lip balm: A classic Easter basket idea.
Temporary tattoos: These tattoos glow in the dark. So fun!
Bunny soap (4 pack): These soaps are such a fun addition to bath time.
Kids’ loofahs (4 pack): A cute loofah makes bath time more fun.
Bath potions (4 pack): A bubble bath experiment is sure to delight at bath time.
Fun bandaids: Always a good choice to have around and these are so cute.
Battery powered toothbrush: A great choice for all kids.
Color changing toothpaste: This makes brushing more fun.
Peeps headband: A cute headband is always fun in an Easter basket.
Summer fun Ideas
Pool toypedos: These are really fun for the pool.
Goggles: Buy now to have for summer fun.
Beach ball: An essential summer toy.
Flip flops: A great idea for adding to Easter baskets.
Bubble wands (6 pack): We love bubble wands. They’re so fun!
Sidewalk chalk: This is a great set of chalk. Grab it now for warmer months.
Mini football: The perfect size football for adding to an Easter basket.
Nerf Super Soaker slingshot: This looks so fun.
Critter blaster: These are a blast for playing at the pool.
Sand bucket & shovel: This is a great set for taking to the beach.
Throw ‘N Stick: A great little activity that would fit perfectly in an Easter basket.
Kite: Kites are a great springtime activity and this one is so affordable.
Binoculars: Always a nice addition to an Easter basket.
Mini bubble blaster: I love that you can just screw on the bubbles and go.
Innertube: Grab an inflatable for pool time fun.
Splash bombs: A great pool toy and it comes in a pack of 4.
Dive rings: Dive rings are great for summer pool time.